
The most striking thing about Palin's speech was that she used such a negative and petty tone in her introduction to the American people. As an Obama supporter, I was starting to worry that the McCain campaign had outsmarted everyone by picking a likable, sympathetic female candidate who would be almost impossible to challenge or attack without running the risk of alienating voters.
But her tone tonight may have insured that she's fair game from here on out. Some of her attacks were ridiculously hypocritical. The most embarrassing example had to be when she made fun of the columns that stood behind Obama during his acceptance speech - from a stage adorned not only with a replica of the Liberty Bell, but also with a massive Jumbotron which alternated between an American flag and images of other famous national landmarks!
There was also her attack on Obama's years as a community organizer (which Giuliani had already made fun of earlier in the night): "I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a community organizer, except that you have actual responsibilities." This line was a huge crowd pleaser, but it's a strange comparison for her to make. Obama worked as a community organizer between 1985 and 1988 - since then, he has attended law school, worked as a lawyer in Chicago, taught at the University of Chicago Law School, served as an Illinois State Senator for 8 years, and then served as a U.S. Senator for 4 years.
In contrast, Palin was still mayor of Wasilla until December 2006, when she was sworn in as Governor of Alaska. So when she mocked Barack Obama's experience level, she was comparing the job she held just 20 months ago to the job he held 20 years ago!
UPDATED 9/4/08:The good news is that a lot of people seem to have had the same reaction to Palin's dismissive condescension. The Detroit Free Press asked a
voter panel for reactions to the speech, and almost all of the panelists who identified themselves as independents were turned off.
Another thing I wonder about is whether the GOP is underestimating how distant and exotic Alaska seems to people east of the Mississippi, which is where most (but not all) of the major battleground states are. I think most people put Alaska in the same category as Obama's home state of Hawaii - and I think Obama would be a much less credible candidate if he was the junior Senator from Hawaii, rather than Illinois, a heavily-populated state that is home to Chicago, one of the major business capitals in the country. If you're a swing voter in Ohio, Pennsylvania, or Michigan, Chicago is a lot closer to home than Wassila.